Developing, Marketing and Promoting My Writing. Part 7: The Frustration of Playing the Long Game

by Chris Harris

Building an audience for my writing is proving an exercise in patience. Social media delivers instant results, but WordPress takes months. Despite publishing daily, the rewards remain elusive. I’m confident the strategy will work, but the waiting is bloody frustrating.

The Frustration of Playing the Long Game

Undoubtedly, one of the greatest frustrations of my attempts to market and promote my book has been the pragmatic decision I made to build much of my marketing strategy around my WordPress blogs. The reasoning was perfectly sound. I already had a reasonably established readership, with around 15,000 reads a year, and it seemed entirely logical to build on what was already working rather than start from scratch. What I hadn’t fully appreciated, despite years of experience with WordPress, was how frustrating this strategy would become when I tried to measure whether my efforts were actually achieving anything.

One of the great advantages of social media is that you find out almost immediately whether something is working. Put a video on Instagram, a post on Facebook or something on X, and within a few hours you have a pretty good idea of the reception it’s going to get. There might be the occasional exception, but generally speaking, within a day or two, whatever you’ve published has wilted away and died. I’ve been making a concerted effort to develop my various social media accounts over the last few months, and whilst the progress has been relatively modest, it’s certainly been measurable. The statistics are there; you can see the improvements, and even when the results are disappointing, at least you know where you stand.

WordPress and blogging, however, are an entirely different beast. It’s an incredibly slow burner, and from my own experience, it generally takes around six months for a blog to reach anything approaching its full potential. Of course, my regular readers will pick up on something I’ve written almost immediately, and I’m enormously grateful for their continued interest and support. But most of my blogs are what are known as evergreen articles, meaning their subject matter remains relevant long after they were originally published. In theory, somebody could be reading something I’ve written today in five years’ time, and there’s no particular reason why they shouldn’t. Indeed, plenty of my older blogs are still being read regularly, years after I first put them online.

The problem is that it takes such an extraordinarily long time for the whole process to crank into gear. Google and the other search engines gradually discover, interpret and index what you’ve written, before eventually deciding where it might deserve to appear in their search results. It’s not quite as simple as publishing something, having Google read it and then suddenly finding yourself inundated with visitors. Search visibility is influenced by all sorts of factors, and the process can be painfully gradual. I know this from experience because I’ve watched it happen over and over again.

Now, around 90% of my WordPress traffic comes from historical blogs, many of which, if I’m being perfectly honest, weren’t particularly good. They were written when I was considerably less knowledgeable about blogging, and their presentation was often pretty rudimentary. Yet lots of these articles have now accumulated more than 500 reads apiece, some 1,500. This isn’t a social media hit; it is not someone aimlessly scrolling through and looking at pictures. A read on WordPress is someone taking their time to click on a blog and read it. Not a 1–3-second engagement, but 4–10 minutes; it is meaningful.

They might only attract three or ten readers in a particular week, but those numbers quietly accumulate, month after month, year after year. It’s the tortoise rather than the hare, and the tortoise, rather annoyingly, doesn’t appear to be in any great hurry.

Meanwhile, around half the blogs currently on my website have been written during the last couple of months, and I would argue that they’re considerably better than much of the older material. They’re better written, more carefully presented, and I’ve made a conscious effort to use WordPress tools to improve accessibility and search engine visibility. I’ve become much more disciplined about the way I approach the whole business, and there’s now a proper strategy behind what I’m doing rather than simply writing something and hoping for the best.

The reward for all this additional effort? Well, at the moment, virtually nobody reads them.

That’s perhaps a slight exaggeration, because my loyal regular readers continue to do so, but in terms of attracting new visitors, the results are pretty dismal. The most irritating part is that I know perfectly well why. I’ve been through this process before, and I know from experience that these things take time. You cannot buck the system, however much you might want to. You just have to sit there, bide your time and trust that the work you’re putting in now will eventually produce results.

This is particularly frustrating because I’m currently writing a blog every single day. I genuinely enjoy writing them, and there’s certainly no shortage of things I want to write about. Indeed, the problem is usually finding enough time to get everything down rather than struggling to think of something to say. But when you’re producing a new article every day, putting considerable thought and effort into it, and seeing virtually no tangible return, it can sometimes feel as though you’re pissing in the wind.

Whilst I know intellectually that this is simply how the process works, that doesn’t necessarily make it any less dispiriting. There are mornings when I look at the statistics and wonder whether I’m wasting my time. Not because I don’t enjoy the writing, because I do, enormously, but because this is supposed to be the cornerstone of my attempts to build an audience for my book and, hopefully, the books that follow it. I’m investing a considerable amount of time in something that, for the moment at least, gives almost no indication of whether it’s succeeding.

The good news is that my own experience tells me it will work. I have the evidence sitting there in the form of numerous older articles, steadily attracting readers long after I published them. There’s no guarantee that every new blog will follow the same pattern, of course, but there’s every reason to believe that many of them will. I just won’t know for another six months, and six months is an awfully long time to wait when you’re working at something every day.

I’ve also started publishing my blogs on Substack, which is another platform I’m trying to develop alongside WordPress. The idea is to give my writing as many opportunities as possible to find an audience, although I have to admit that my attempts to promote everything properly across the various social media platforms have been pretty inadequate so far. It’s not through a lack of enthusiasm or willingness to learn. It’s simply that I haven’t yet managed to establish a system that allows me to do everything efficiently, and at the moment there are so many different demands on my time that something inevitably has to give.

I’m hoping that by Christmas I’ll have got a much better grip on the whole operation, particularly the business of promoting the blogs rather than simply writing and publishing them. There’s little point in creating all this material if I’m not making a reasonable effort to tell people it exists. But equally, I don’t want to spend so much time marketing my writing that I no longer have enough time to actually write anything. Getting that balance right is proving rather more difficult than I originally anticipated.

But, in the same way I can predict, from experience, with my online trading business, what I will be selling in a month, I can, with the help of AI and my knowledge of WordPress, be certain that in four to six months there should be a large upshot in traffic to my blogs.

Make both our days by buying a copy of my book!

Something About England: Amazon.co.uk: Harris, Mr Christopher, Turner, Louise: 9798181129351: Books

Welcome to Denham, a fictitious Sussex village where behind respectable doors, well-tended gardens and familiar faces, things have a habit of going badly wrong.

Obsession, ambition, deception, jealousy and petty rivalry run through this collection of tragi-comical and satirical short stories. From poltergeists and lottery winners to cricket club feuds and environmental disasters, ordinary people embark on discovering just how quickly an ordinary life can unravel into an extraordinary mess.

Darkly funny, occasionally poignant and populated by characters who are rarely quite what they seem, these stories explore the peculiarities of Middle England, and the uncomfortable territory between respectability and ruin.

Leave a Reply